moreno-valley-reloadedBy Corey Arvin, Staff Writer

It felt like David versus Goliath. The odds were stacked against them – and they knew it. Their donor base was small in comparison to the big-money Political Action Committees (PAC) that poured hundreds of thousands of dollars into their bid to save Mayor Tom Owings from recall.

This election, however, couldn’t be bought.

According to Alicia Espinoza, a founding member of the Concerned Citizens of Moreno Valley, the group scrounged up $19,000 to finance their recall efforts against Owings last year. She credits the rest of their victory to fervent support from local voters exhausted by political impropriety.

“We were pinching our pennies. We were recycling cans and plastic bottles. All of us invested in very different ways,” said Espinoza.

“I think this recall will change the dynamics of our politics if you want to be an elected official. They are not going to be king makers. They’re going to be here to serve the people, and if not, they are going to be recalled.”

On June 3, the group’s recall wishes were fulfilled as voters rescinded Owings from the City Council. Owings’ removal from the council was the first part of a long, arduous battle to level politics in Moreno Valley and restore the city’s tarnished image, said Espinoza.

With Owings gone, recall supporters swiftly turned their attention back to Baca. Baca, who is Mayor Pro Tem, is most likely to succeed Owings, which has left recall supporters uncomfortable in the meantime.

A group called “Residents Ending Corruption and Lies” turned in petition signatures to recall Baca to the City Clerk on Monday. Baca was served a notice of intent to recall in January. The City Clerk approved a petition to recall Baca on Feb. 10.

Calls seeking comment from Baca were not returned.

George Price, the city’s former parks and recreation director, overcame five contenders to be elected to the Council June 3 to replace Owings’ seat. Price garnered more votes than Jose Garcia, Omorefe Igbinosa , Carlos Ketcham, Brian Lowell, and Susan Gilmore Owings, the former mayor’s wife.

Price will complete Owings’ term, which would have ended in 2016. Another City Councilmember will be appointed Mayor to replace Owings’ seat.

Last year, recall supporters made their intentions to unseat several city councilmembers very clear, including Baca, Molina, and Former Councilman Marcello Co. Co escaped a potential recall bid when he resigned from his seat following his arrest and conviction on unrelated fraud charges.

“Our plan was to go after everyone,” said Espinoza. “We didn’t do all of (the city councilmembers) at the same time. The group had strategically decided, do one at a time.”

“Because there are so many different districts, it’s very hard to find volunteers. I can’t image doing 3 recalls at the same time with such low volunteers. With Baca, we had about 9 volunteers and 5 walkers, and the rest were at the recall tent on Frederick and Cottonwood.”

According to Espinoza, since Feb. 10, volunteers canvassed District 5 to collect signatures and support from residents. Some of the volunteers included retirees. Their work culminated on Sunday.

Most recent photo of the Moreno Valley City Council. (L to R): recall target Councilwoman Victoria Baca, Councilman Jesse Molina, recalled Mayor Tom Owings, targeted Councilman Yxstian Gutierrez and retiring Councilman Richard Stewart.
Most recent photo of the Moreno Valley City Council. (L to R): recall target Councilwoman Victoria Baca, Councilman Jesse Molina, recalled Mayor Tom Owings, targeted Councilman Yxstian Gutierrez and retiring Councilman Richard Stewart.

Moreno Valley had been mired in accusations of corruption and unscrupulous activity for several years before reaching a fever pitch last year when Owings became the subject of a political corruption investigation by the FBI and representatives from the Riverside County District Attorney’s office. The homes of Owings and several other councilmembers, including Councilwoman Victoria Baca, were subsequently searched by investigators. Iddo Benzeevi, president of Highland Fairview, a warehouse development company, was also the target of office search by investigators. Benzeevi had been accused of corruption-related ties with Moreno Valley City Councilmembers.

Councilman Yxstian Gutierrez is currently facing a lawsuit to remove him from office. Gutierrez was appointed to the City Council to replace Co.

“This whole recall was a prelude of the FBI Investigation. The purpose of doing the recall was to send a message to every elected official that we the people will no longer be supporting special interest groups. You will not support developers, you will serve the people,” said Espinoza.

Recall proponents like Espinoza are hoping a successful recall of Owings, who represented District 3, could bring a fresh start to Moreno Valley politics.

Denise Fleming, Ed.D, Vice President of the Moreno Valley School Board, considers herself a proud resident who has lived in the city for the past 25 years. While she too is hopeful Moreno Valley politics will be reset by the ongoing recall effort, she also believes the leadership needs to be emphasized.

Fleming has had to cultivate resources and build grassroots coalitions without city council support. With the help of the local NAACP and National Black Women’s Council, they have been able to develop small scholarships, create health programs, including drug and alcohol abuse education.

“We do this with no backing from the city itself because we don’t get that support from the city,” she said.

Fleming says Moreno Valley is in need of “visionaries” to lead the city forward.

“I love the city. I think it’s a wonderful city with great potential and you see that when a small entity is able to take on a large dynamic with a recall. It’s special here because you won’t see that in every city,” said Fleming.

According to Espinoza, changing the landscape of Moreno Valley requires a strong stance against the ideas that don’t improve the lives of residents, such as excessive warehouse development.

“Our residents deserve more than a bunch of warehouses. Just because we have a lot of minorities here doesn’t mean we don’t deserve better. We have a voice that will be heard … and we do vote.”

The recall of Baca is likely to be added to the voter ballot in November.