
Once unanimously-supported by the City Council, proponents back-peddle on appeal.
By Corey Arvin, Staff Writer
After more than one year of litigation – and about $100,000 in legal fees later – Moreno Valley officials dropped their vigorous legal appeal against March Joint Powers Authority (JPA) in a settlement decided during a closed-door City Council meeting on July 1.
The lawsuit, which was heavily criticized, also perplexed many residents.
March JPA is an agency comprised of Riverside County and several cities in the county, including Moreno Valley. The agency manages 4,400 acres of former active duty base territory.
Moreno Valley sued March JPA last year over plans to develop the March LifeCare medical complex, objecting to allowing the developer more time to build out the proposed project. But Sacramento Superior Court Judge Shelleyanne Chang rejected Moreno Valley’s lawsuit in February citing that Moreno Valley was a part of March JPA.
Despite the judge’s decision, in April some council members supported filing an appeal.

Initially, when the City Council voted to pursue legal action against March JPA, it had unanimous support led by now-ousted Mayor Tom Owings. Councilwoman and Mayor Pro-Tem Victoria Baca, who once supported the lawsuit, pivoted on her position about March JPA from one year ago. According to a Press-Enterprise article published July 1, in a statement Baca said March JPA helped create jobs for the city’s residents through development at Meridian Business Park and that she welcomed the March LifeCare project. Baca is also one of eight commission members of March JPA, Moreno Valley has two seats on the commission.
Last week, a recall petition aimed at Baca was determined to have enough valid signatures to add her to November’s election ballot. Owings, who was also sought in a recall bid, was ousted in May.
Phone calls to Baca seeking comment regarding the settlement agreement were not returned.
Lori Stone, Executive Director of March JPA, expressed enthusiasm that the development of the March LifeCare campus could continue moving forward since 7,200 jobs were at stake. “I talked to the developer and he’s been pretty matter of fact that he has users with property in escrow and they ask about it almost on a daily basis. This helps them move forward.”

In retrospect, Stone said she could not understand how Moreno Valley would have gained from the lawsuit and why they filed an appeal.
“I can’t make sense of it to be perfectly honest,” she said.
Former Moreno Valley City Councilmember Bill Batey, who had represented the city on the March JPA Commission, considered the lawsuit and subsequent decision to appeal the judge’s ruling a head-scratcher and said he had “no idea” why the City Council supported the lawsuit from the beginning.
“There is no logic to file an appeal knowing the road you’re going down other than to stall the medical center project. What I can see is that as long as this lawsuit remained, March Lifecare can’t move forward … and it could have damaged prospective tenants because of the lawsuit,” Batey said.
Batey called the city’s approximate $100,000 in legal expenses to support litigation, which came from the general fund, wasteful spending that could have been allocated to more deserving projects around Moreno Valley.
“It was a big waste of money. We could have put that money into maintenance, repairing roads, or keeping police officers on the street,” he added.
Batey, who served on the Moreno Valley City Council from 1996 to 2012, said repairing the city’s reputation and relationship with residents is going to take time, but the first step of removing controversial city councilmembers is a significant first step. However, changing the business community’s perception of the city, particularly developers, could take longer.
“Anybody who has had any business with Moreno Valley will be more cautious about their dealings with the city’s staff,” said Batey.
“I think there will be some changes to the city’s upper management. That would not surprise me. You have to have trust and have confidence in your (advisors) and I’m not sure that trust has been put together yet,” he said.
According to Moreno Valley City Attorney Suzanne Bryant, the settlement still needs to be finalized and there is no time frame for when that will occur.

