By S. E. Williams, 

online pharmacy cytotec no prescription pharmacy

Staff Writer

defunded_1

At least five independent audits in the previous three years revealed how state and county officials, who failed repeatedly over the last ten years in their fiduciary oversight responsibilities of Proposition 63 funding, were continuously granted dispensation relative to their negligence. The government agencies involved were afforded repeated opportunities to modify procedures and remedy inadequacies. However, when a recent audit of local nonprofit agency the DuBois Institute revealed a myriad of similar shortcomings in its administration of a Proposition 63 funded program, the Riverside County Department of Mental Health immediately froze the program’s funding, shuttered its program and cancelled its contract.

When a valued and respected outreach program for African American youth and families was abruptly halted by Riverside County Mental officials, student participants and their parents were left without options for program completion.

The program, Building Resiliency in African American Families, was introduced as a three-tiered initiative. It included parenting classes, cognitive behavioral therapy designed to help young people cope with stress and/or trauma and Afro-centric Rites of Passage training for students between the ages of 12 and 16. The initiative was created and managed by Licensed Clinical and Forensic Psychologist, Dr. E. M. Abdulmumin through his nonprofit organization, the DuBois Institute.

Students, near the conclusion of this year’s nine-month Rite of Passage training were left hanging just before graduation; staff went home unpaid; and surprised parents were disappointed. Some members of the community reacted with frustration, while other raised suspicions of disparate treatment.

Proposition 63, the Mental Health Services Act was passed by California voters in 2004. It created a funding source designed to help close the gap in mental health services by expanding mental health programs that worked well and funding new, innovative and proactive approaches to mental health services with a focus on underserved communities. The initiative is funded by a one percent tax on residents with incomes above one million dollars.

In December 2010, the DuBois Institute was awarded a near quarter of a million dollar contract by the Riverside County Department of Mental Health for its Building Resilience in African American Families program under the auspices of Proposition 63’s Early Intervention (PEI) Program.

The contract, designed to aid in combating mental health problems in African American families, covered the period July 1, 2011 to June 30, 2012 and was renewable for a four-year period. The renewal option raised the contract’s lifetime fiscal potential to well over a million dollars.

defunded_2

online pharmacy buy glucophage no insurance with best prices today in the USA

In February, as the agency neared the end of its second renewal option and for the first time in its nearly four years of providing the contracted services, DuBois Institute (DI) received a letter from the Riverside County Department of Mental Health (RCDMH). It advised DI of the department’s plans to conduct a program, administrative and fiscal review of the agency on March 3, 2015.

In an exclusive interview with The VOICE, Abdulmumin explained that during DI’s contractual history with the county his organization never experienced any significant issues with oversight. “They do a cost report at the end of each year to see how much money is spent,” he explained and continued, “this is done each year prior to approval of the next year’s budget.”

When asked whether there were ever any difficulties in the renewal process? He explained there were in fact a couple of items identified over the years but they were fixable. “There was nothing other than that,” he concluded.

Abdulmumin went on to explain how the county’s formal notification of the audit came out of the blue. “They [RCDMH] said I was the first to be audited in this manner and this was the first time auditors were coming to the office.”

According to Abdulmumin, the county’s Department of Mental Health officials sent a list of what they wanted to review in advance of the visit. “It included requests for information regarding the program’s implementation,” he added.

On the day of the audit, five representatives from RCDMH arrived at DI. Upon their arrival, Abdulmumin realized they were all county employees from the Department of Mental Health’s Early Prevention Team. He knew all of them.

defunded_3

“On the day of the audit we were well prepared,” Abdulmumin stated. “They went through the records we provided at their request. They called us [into the conference room] periodically if they had questions. At the end of the audit my accountant and I sat for further questioning and feedback,” he continued.

According to Abdulmumin, the feedback was broad with comments about the things his team had done right and recommendations regarding areas in need of improvement.

When asked whether the audit process in general or the feedback session specifically raised any red flags as to whether RCDMH was looking for something specific? Abdulmumin replied, “I just gave them the benefit of the doubt because I had pretty good relationships with all of them.”

At the conclusion of the audit Abdulmumin stated the audit team gave no hint it would be following up for additional information. “There was no indication they wanted more,” he said. He subsequently learned the auditors did want more. In a letter dated March 6, RCDMH requested more documentation related to the administrative and fiscal parts of the review.

The letter requested the information be provided within ten business days. It further stated if the requested information was not provided by March 20, 2015, “it will be noted in the final monitoring report.” The letter made no mention of a possible termination.

“The questions weren’t that difficult,” Abdulmumin explained and added, “We got it to them by 4:30 pm on the due date by email.”

What Abdulmumin did not realize at the time he pushed the send button on his electronic response was his inbox held a message from RCDMH—a message received a couple of hours earlier. The communication was very pointed. It stated in part, “ . . . pursuant to the termination provision of your organization’s agreement with the Riverside County Department of Mental Health, this letter is sent to serve as RCDMH’s written notice to your organization that your Agreement [with the county] will be terminated effective March 31, 2015.”

A review of the termination letter by The VOICE revealed a myriad of revelations by RCMDH as justification for contract termination. The letter highlighted failures by the DuBois Institute to follow by-laws requirements; violations of records retention requirements; incomplete financial records related to payroll and miscellaneous expenditures, in addition to missing bank and previous year cost reconciliations; incomplete personnel files of agency contractors, volunteers and employees as well as uncertified time sheets; challenges to the legitimacy of the agency’s Board of Directors; and finally, scope of work violations that ranged from program participants not meeting the target population requirements defined as African American children and their parent/guardians that live in communities with high rates of poverty and community violence. It also claimed several participants did not meet the program’s other criteria.

These reasons drove the county’s decision to discontinue the Building Resilience in African American Families Program with the DuBois Institute. Abdulmumin acknowledged the agency’s findings yet believed everything in the report was reconcilable.

As program participants and the community-at-large struggle to understand the program’s termination, Abdulmumin has retained legal representation and is prepared to fight for the program’s survival.

The VOICE made several attempts by telephone and email to explore this issue with the Riverside County Department of Mental Health. The agency has yet to respond to these requests.


UPDATE: County Responds to Community Concerns and Agreed to Expand Audit of the DuBois Institute

By Stephanie Williams, Staff Writer

At the regular Riverside County Board of Supervisors meeting last Tuesday, advocates for the DuBois Institute urged officials to consider reinstating the DuBois Institute’s contract with the county through June when it was originally due to expire.

During the meeting members of the community challenged officials to understand the needs of young people helped by DuBois Institute programs – who are now left without access to the center.

Although the Board was noticeably reluctant to reinstate the initiative, it agreed to expand the audit to include a greater portion of the nearly five year period the DuBois Institute contracted with the county – the initial audit only covered the period November through December 2014.

Fourth District Supervisor John J. Benoit responded to community concerns by sharing how the county provides similar services countywide; and, said he appreciated the heartwarming stories about how the group’s work affects children.

Benoit then tempered those comments by stating the initial audit uncovered “some serious, serious problems.” He added, “We’re going to get to the bottom of it … but it is not right to just leave the impression that we just don’t care.”

“We care a lot about all of the issues you talked about,” Benoit continued and then stated, “We also care about making sure that the taxpayers’ dollars are spent appropriately.”

In an exclusive interview with Riverside Public Information Officer Raymond Smith, he confirmed the Board took no action relative to the advocates’ request to reconsider the termination. According to Smith, state law prohibits the Board from taking action in a meeting on any item that is not included on the agenda for that meeting.

Smith further advised there is no timeline for completion of the expanded audit and confirmed it will be made public on completion.

The VOICE will continue to follow this story.